Annuity Guys Resources

Are 8 Percent Annuity Returns in 2025 Too Good to be True?

Annuity Salesman asks: “How would you like an eight percent compounded return? -Guaranteed!” Misled customer replies, “Where do I sign-up?”


Is the question/statement an outright lie? No, but it is one of the reasons so many people are confused about how annuities really work.


The five, six, eight, and even ten percent growth claims in the annuity world are most typically associated with a **guaranteed roll-up calculation that will be used to produce a payout number for a future lifetime income amount. Yes – that is a good thing and when annuities have been sold with the promise of producing a reliable future lifetime income, these calculations can be a valuable benefit. However, if a high return on your investment is expected based on these claims you will be disappointed.

Unfortunately, most annuity purchasers do not understand that the 8% percent roll-up is a future income growth formula that is not available to them as a lump sum withdrawal. Thus, potential annuity clients are pitched on a 8 percent compounded return; so, they often don’t comprehend that when the salesman says growth for future income, what the salesman really means is that you can only use the 8 percent roll-up number to calculate future income. You cannot make a withdrawal to get the whole amount with 8 percent growth and then go buy a new home in Florida.


In a prolonged low rate environment like we have been experiencing, it can be hard to just say NO when we hear some of these high rates of return that are not fairly explained. So, just be sure to clarify that the rate offered will generate an outcome that will meet your financial objectives.


The good news is that some annuity providers have seen the confusion that has arisen from these offerings; and are designing products that are easier to understand while prohibiting agents from using “unfair smoke and mirrors type marketing tactics” to produce more business.


Just remember what your mom always told you… “If it seems too good to be true, it probably is…”


Videos are educational and conceptual only and not a solicitation. They are not to be considered investment, insurance, tax or legal advice. It is recommended that you work with licensed professionals for individualized advice before making any important financial decisions. Annuities are not FDIC insured and their guarantees are based on the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State Guarantee Associations, while offering specific protections, are not the same as FDIC insurance.

More Annuity Videos

April 10, 2026
We see it everywhere: 8% guarantees, 10% income for life. When people call in, they often tell us things like, “I talked to someone who said 8% was the floor—the minimum I can earn,” or “This other place showed me how I can get 10% cash flow for life on my assets.” And while those claims can be true, they often leave out some very important details.
A man looks thoughtfully beside a graphic featuring an upward stock chart, a glowing digital cube, and vintage scrolls.
March 30, 2026
One of the most common questions we hear is: Do I need an annuity? And if so, how much of my money should go into one? Today, let’s walk through how to think about that. The reality is simple: everyone’s situation is different. Some people may want nothing in an annuity. Others may choose 10% , and some may allocate as much as 50% . It all depends on your foundational income needs and your comfort level with risk.
A surprised person looks at a swirling vortex of financial documents, charts, and brochures against a dark green background.
March 10, 2026
What if you could potentially increase your retirement income by 23% — without taking on more market risk? That's not wishful thinking. According to the 2025 Goldman Sachs Asset Management Retirement Survey & Insights Report, blending annuities into a retirement plan could significantly increase the income you can safely spend each year.¹ And in today's uncertain economy — with inflation, market volatility, and rising living costs — that's an opportunity worth understanding. I'm Eric Judy, a Retirement Income Certified Professional, Investment Advisor Representative, and co-founder of the Annuity Guys. Today, I want to walk you through what Goldman Sachs calls the hybrid income strategy — how combining traditional investments with guaranteed income from annuities could give retirees greater confidence and stability in their retirement years. My goal is simple: to help you make smarter, more informed decisions about your retirement income. No hype. No pressure.
Show More