Annuity Guys Resources

Exposing Why Some Advisors Love or Hate Annuities

“Why can’t we all just get along?” It seems that the spirit of divisive partisan politics has invaded the investment world of annuities vs securities and more specifically fixed index annuities. For a myriad of reasons it seems many advisors end up in one camp or the other – loving or hating annuities while at times masking their true bias!



Investment broker types typically avoid or hate fixed index annuities but love promoting variable annuities# and other securities products. Insurance agents on the other hand love fixed index annuities and have little appreciation for variable annuities# or investing in securities… [continued below video]


[continued] …Brokers want to make a commission from selling you mutual funds or variable annuities and then collect trail fees from their assets under management. Insurance agents typically make one commission from an insurance sale including annuities. There’s not really that much difference, so why is there so much animosity? They all want your money! That is how they get paid. Brokers and insurance agents want to get your money for their products or management since they are in serious competition for your assets.


Let’s face it, as the baby boomer generation enters retirement, more and more assets are moving from aggressive growth allocations into safer money options like annuities. Retirees face the challenge of turning their savings into lifetime income and they have to protect every dollar they can from the potential of market loss – yet many brokers don’t understand that mode of thinking.


They surmise that even if you lose 30% this year, you’ll hopefully be able to get it back in the next three to four years because that is how markets should work. Most brokers are accumulation specialists. They try to tell you the hot stocks and funds to buy but they don’t really know how to properly create a balanced portfolio that protects and grows assets while **guaranteeing a retirement income that you cannot outlive.


That being said, fixed index annuities are not the panacea for all your financial needs. They are wonderful for creating a secure income or providing reasonable safer growth – but they are not securities and they should not be compared unfairly to them. Unfortunately, most consumers that are transitioning into retirement have been conditioned to think in terms of accumulation, so they are more comfortable using terms from what they have learned throughout years of “investing”. The transition into annuities for income, limited growth, and safety typically means learning to talk more about the safer return OF your money with reasonable growth – not the sizable returns ON your money that is left at risk.


Too many insurance agents try to talk like brokers and show off the “sizzle” of the 8% income rider growth formulas – even though it may not be the right annuity, it’s the easier “sell” because consumers can relate to the “growth guarantees”. So annuities get the occasional black eye when they are represented incorrectly by miss-informed or at times bad advisors who don’t really understand the value of educating themselves or their clients about the proper use of annuities. They are definitely not the White Hat Good-Annuity Guys®, they pretend to be! In our humble opinion, your best advisor choice is to work with a Fiduciary Registered Investment Advisor having extensive experience with securities and annuities, who takes a balanced, holistic approach to retirement planning.

Videos are educational and conceptual only and not a solicitation. They are not to be considered investment, insurance, tax or legal advice. It is recommended that you work with licensed professionals for individualized advice before making any important financial decisions. Annuities are not FDIC insured and their guarantees are based on the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State Guarantee Associations, while offering specific protections, are not the same as FDIC insurance.

More Annuity Videos

A man looks thoughtfully beside a graphic featuring an upward stock chart, a glowing digital cube, and vintage scrolls.
March 30, 2026
One of the most common questions we hear is: Do I need an annuity? And if so, how much of my money should go into one? Today, let’s walk through how to think about that. The reality is simple: everyone’s situation is different. Some people may want nothing in an annuity. Others may choose 10% , and some may allocate as much as 50% . It all depends on your foundational income needs and your comfort level with risk.
A surprised person looks at a swirling vortex of financial documents, charts, and brochures against a dark green background.
March 10, 2026
What if you could potentially increase your retirement income by 23% — without taking on more market risk? That's not wishful thinking. According to the 2025 Goldman Sachs Asset Management Retirement Survey & Insights Report, blending annuities into a retirement plan could significantly increase the income you can safely spend each year.¹ And in today's uncertain economy — with inflation, market volatility, and rising living costs — that's an opportunity worth understanding. I'm Eric Judy, a Retirement Income Certified Professional, Investment Advisor Representative, and co-founder of the Annuity Guys. Today, I want to walk you through what Goldman Sachs calls the hybrid income strategy — how combining traditional investments with guaranteed income from annuities could give retirees greater confidence and stability in their retirement years. My goal is simple: to help you make smarter, more informed decisions about your retirement income. No hype. No pressure.
October 3, 2025
“Eight Percent Annual Annuity Returns”… or even better! Before You Lock In Rates… Discover Up To 15% Income For Life or how about up-to 33% More Income for Life! Where did we find these amazing offers? Believe it or not, right in the Ad section at the top and bottom of the page when we searched Google for the word “annuity”. Surely these offers must really exist or they wouldn’t put them on Google. In fact, I know these offers do exist — unfortunately, just not the expected results for the people this advertising targets. These offers are the classic bait and switch or maybe I would call them bait and twist. How so? Let me translate it from marketing speak into English – “eight percent annual return” translates into a captive income formula (not an actual return on your money!) that never allows you to walk away with that so called eight percent return. Want the 15%? You’ll have to wait to start your income at about age 90 to get that one, and the 33% more income for life pitch [continued below video…]
Show More